Episode 9: Let’s Go For a Ride

Episode 9: Let’s Go For a Ride

We visit the crime scenes in Argos and drive the escape route police think the killer took when he abducted Darlene. Prosecutor Chipman points out the Peltz home, the Hulse home and we stop at the woods where Darlene’s body was found. Prosecutor Chipman gives his...
Episode 10: Look at the Deeds

Episode 10: Look at the Deeds

We study land records and see that a family farm near where Darlene’s body was found is tied to a suspect in the case, who was convicted of another nearby crime. Those connections lead to more and more connections regarding this suspect, so we confront him. Courtesy:...
Episode 11: Bad Seed

Episode 11: Bad Seed

We sort through tips from 1984 that suggested a fugitive who was on the run in Indiana during Darlene’s murder could’ve killed her. We go to his hometown to dig through records, interview one of his victims and try to interview him. Courtesy: Indiana State Police...
Episode 12: P.I.’s Best Lead

Episode 12: P.I.’s Best Lead

We interview a private investigator who reviewed the case and came up with yet another person of interest based on pre and post-crime behavior. We obtain interviews that were done with witnesses who had reason to believe this man was the one who killed Darlene....
Episode 13: Untangling Misinformation

Episode 13: Untangling Misinformation

We discover we’ve been given bad information about a person of interest. Either we were lied to or those in charge are mistaken. We go back to Argos and find the truth about all of it, which leads us down another new path. Courtesy: Indiana State Police Episode Info...